Journal of Global Health: Home Journal of Global Health
Watch: Survival: The Story of Global Health - FREE
JoGH Recommends:

Peer Review Conference



Creative Commons Licence
This work is licensed under a
Creative Commons Attribution
4.0 International License
.


Alfred Papali, Janet V Diaz, E Jane Carter, Juliana C Ferreira, Rob Fowler, Tewodros H Gebremariam, Stephen B Gordon, Burton W Lee, Srinivas Murthy, Elisabeth D Riviello, T Eoin West, and Neill KJ Adhikari

The burden of respiratory and critical illness is high worldwide, yet specialist care is underrepresented in low- and middle-income countries (LMICs) [1]. For many areas of medicine, the past decade has witnessed tremendous growth in global health opportunities for trainees; however, these opportunities tend to be restricted to individual institutions and geographic regions and academic global pulmonary and critical care medicine (PCCM) remains a relatively novel concept [2]. Consequently, PCCM fellows and junior faculty at institutions with limited global health mentorship have little guidance in building successful global health careers.

This paper highlights various pathways to develop a successful academic career in PCCM and global health. Ranging from traditional academic medicine to private practice, professional societies to transnational health policy bodies, the challenges of balancing international work with clinical and other professional demands are discussed in Table 1 provides examples of and links to specific opportunities. A more comprehensive discussion with personal anecdotes and advice from current global PCCM faculty can be found separately (publication pending, Journal of Global Health Reports).

Table 1.  Career options in academic global pulmonary and critical care medicine
Pathway Examples Locations Links
Professional societies ATS-MECOR USA https://www.thoracic.org/about/global-public-health/mecor-program/
ESICM global intensive care working group International https://www.esicm.org/resources/thematics/ global -intensive-care-2/
World Health Organization IMAI Global http://www.who.int/careers/en/
Physician-scientist global health training Johns Hopkins University USA http://www.globalncd.org/global-health-track/
Malawi-Liverpool-Wellcome Trust Clinical Research Programme Malawi/UK https://www.mlw.mw/
Faith-based/NGO Kijabe Hospital Kenya http://kijabehospital.org/blog/eccco-program
St. Luke Foundation Haiti http://www.stlukehaiti.org/health-care
Educational partnerships East Africa Training Initiative (EATI) Ethiopia https://eatiethiopia.org/
REACH Haiti http://haecc.org
Medical ethics MERETI Middle East http://www.mereti-network.net/
Pediatrics WFPICCS Global https://www.wfpiccs.org
PECC-Kenya Kenya http://www.pecc-kenya.org

NGO – non-governmental organization, ATS – American Thoracic Society, MECOR – Methods in Epidemiological, Clinical and Operations Research, ESICM – European Society of Intensive Care Medicine, IMAI – Integrated Management of Adult Illness, REACH – Research and Education consortium for Acute Care in Haiti, MERETI – Middle East Research Training Initiative, WFPICCS – World Federation of Pediatric and Intensive Care Societies, PECC – Pediatric Emergency and Critical Care



CAPACITY-BUILDING

Building both clinical and research capacity in LMICs is paramount to generate locally relevant health research that informs practice, policy and population health. The importance of training the next generation of young clinicians and investigators in LMICs with adequate mentoring is increasingly recognized [3]. Two examples include the East Africa Training Initiative (EATI) and the American Thoracic Society (ATS) Methods in Epidemiologic, Clinical, and Operations Research (MECOR) Program.

EATI, a PCCM training program in Addis Ababa, is a partnership between Ethiopian physician leadership and American academic medical centers that began in 2013. It is creating a cadre of well-trained physicians through a two-year intensive fellowship program focusing on clinical, research, advocacy and telemedicine development [4]. International faculty have a continuous presence, with each faculty member being on site for a month at a time.

MECOR is a capacity-building course designed to help PCCM clinicians, academicians, and public health professionals conduct research relevant to LMICs. The program organizes courses in multiple global regions annually and boasts >1800 graduates over 25 years [5]. International and local faculty volunteers teach the three week-long courses and provide distance mentoring. Thus, faculty have the opportunity to get involved in education and research in LMICs with either very short trips or from their home institution.

WORLD HEALTH ORGANIZATION (WHO)

WHO addresses health policy by focusing on underlying social, environmental and economic determinants of health and developing evidence-based guidance. Its engagement is of particular relevance in LMICs with insufficient clinical, health policy, and research expertise. Areas of activity relevant to PCCM abound as evolving patterns of global burden of disease have increased attention to acute care [6] and non-communicable illness. Focus areas include pulmonary infection treatment, tobacco-related mortality reduction, air quality improvement, road safety initiatives and emergency and essential surgical care. The WHO increasingly views critical care as an essential component given its substantial role in recent outbreaks.

Other than in outbreaks, WHO generally does not employ clinicians to carry out direct patient care. Clinical expertise, multilingualism and geographic mobility are valued skills for full-time professional positions. Temporary consultant positions for education and training, especially in LMIC environments with limited capacity, are a common WHO role. Variable-duration unpaid internships provide practical experience for trainees, and certain countries sponsor “Junior Professional Officer” positions to provide early-career young professionals with practical experience in multilateral technical co-operation.

.  Photo: ATS MECOR Latin America Level 1 group photo, Mexico, 2019 (from the collection of Juliana Ferreira, Sao Paulo, Brazil; used with permission).
jogh-10-010313-Fa


PHYSICIAN-SCIENTIST PATHWAY FOR GLOBAL HEALTH

Research in LMICs should be of the highest quality, clinically relevant to local health needs, and emphasize capacity development. Because less research is performed in LMICs, whatever is done needs to be done very well. Grounding research in local health needs can optimize clinical utility and lead to clinical questions of greater scope with the potential to improve outcomes for a larger population. Researchers in LMICs, where few PCCM training programs exist, have an obligation to develop the next generation of researchers and policy-makers who can implement research results.

For PCCM trainees aiming to become independent physician-scientists focused on LMICs, there are several considerations. First, global health can take many forms, and while a substantial time commitment in the field is essential to long-term impact, important contributions from analysis of global data sets are possible [7]. Video conferencing and social networking can facilitate international collaboration. Second, for fellowship training, select an institution with success in nurturing independent physician-scientists. Equally important is identifying a qualified and supportive mentoring team and acquisition of specific training in global health knowledge, leadership, and research ethics. Third, trainees should learn to be productive academically. Grant-writing skills, first author abstracts and manuscripts, training grants and career development awards are key. Protected research time is short and precious, so crafting a timeline and realistic goals early-on is essential.

FAITH-BASED HEALTH CARE ORGANIZATIONS

Faith-based health care organizations (FBH) account for a substantial part of health care in many LMICs since virtually all major religions encourage caring for the poor and the vulnerable in society [8]. There is substantial variation in activities of FBHs globally, but one example relevant to PCCM is the Emergency Critical Care Clinical Officer program (ECCCO) Program at Kijabe Hospital (Kenya), which is owned and operated by the Africa Inland Church. ECCCO is an 18-month training program for physicians, nurse anesthetists and clinical officers to provide long-term, sustainable, quality acute care. Many trainees and faculty from HIC academic institutions have volunteered as clinical mentors.

FBH work is not for everyone. One should explore fully the institution’s practices to ensure comfort with faith traditions, since philosophies and practices can vary widely. FBHs are not immune to issues of limited human and material resources, high attrition of workers, and poor governance that plague many hospitals. Nevertheless, FBH work can be rich and rewarding for those comfortable in this environment.

PRIVATE PRACTICE

Finding the balance between clinical work and global health can be challenging in an academic environment. An alternative is to split work between private or community-based practice and global health pursuits. Part-time private practice may offer sufficient salary support to offset non-clinical time and may provide the flexibility for overseas activities. However, this approach may be more suitable for inpatient practice and may challenge personal and family development. Feasibility is likely to be contingent on supportive features of the HIC private practice setting, since demands of each practice can vary widely. For individuals with such flexibility, the global health private practice model may prove to be an attractive “road less traveled.”

PEDIATRIC CONSIDERATIONS

All of these career paths are applicable to pediatric PCCM. International societies, such as the World Federation of Pediatric and Intensive Care Societies, have made global training opportunities and capacity building a focus, given the tremendous global needs. Additionally, several training programs in North America have robust institutional linkages based on established global health centers in many children’s hospitals. Training programs for pediatric critical and emergency care have begun (for example, in Kenya) and are starting to scale up in other regions. Opportunities for advocacy, education, research, and clinical service abound, and interested early-career individuals can access these opportunities through any of these pathways.

CONCLUSION

There is no single pathway to a successful career in academic global PCCM. Specialist clinical skills, public health, research and teaching are all needed in government, international public health, non-governmental organization (NGO) and faith-based settings. Determination and creativity during training are crucial and should feed into strategic thinking and a 5-year individual development plan, which can help to articulate specific goals and career strategies [9]. Participating in global health-focused professional society opportunities also provides face-to-face networking opportunities between trainees and potential mentors, who can provide career advice and potentially offer opportunities to join existing projects [10]. Trainees and junior faculty interested in academic global PCCM will find innumerable obstacles to developing this non-traditional career pathway, particularly in institutions where global health is less emphasized. However, the strategies outlined herein offer diverse and feasible pathways for success.

Notes

[1] Funding: This work received no specific funding.

[2] Authorship contributions: JVD, EJC, JCF, RF, THG, SBG, BWL, SM and TEW authored individual sections of the manuscript. AP collated individual contributions and organized into a coherent manuscript. All authors reviewed the manuscript for content.

[3] Competing Interests: The authors completed the ICMJE Unified Competing Interest form (available upon request from the corresponding author), and declare no conflicts of interest.

REFERENCES

[1] JV Diaz, ED Riviello, A Papali, NKJ Adhikari, and JC Ferreira. Global Critical Care: Moving Forward in Resource-Limited Settings. Ann Glob Health.. 2019;;85::3 . DOI: 10.5334/aogh.2413. [30741504]

[2] CM North, EF Attia, KE Rudd, T Siddharthan, A Papali, and B Çoruh. Global health-related training opportunities. A national survey of pulmonary and critical care medicine fellowship programs. Ann Am Thorac Soc.. 2019;;16::1171--8. . DOI: 10.1513/AnnalsATS.201812-856OC. [31199665]

[3] AG Lescano, CR Cohen, T Raj, L Rispel, PJ Garcia, and JR Zunt. Strengthening mentoring in low- and middle-income countries to advance global health research: An overview. Am J Trop Med Hyg.. 2019;;100:(1 Suppl):3--8. . DOI: 10.4269/ajtmh.18-0556. [30430982]

[4] CB Sherman, EJ Carter, O Braendli, A Getaneh, and NW Schluger. The East African Training Initiative. A model training program in pulmonary and critical care medicine for low-income countries. Ann Am Thorac Soc.. 2016;;13::451--5. . DOI: 10.1513/AnnalsATS.201510-673OC. [26991950]

[5] CM Patino, DH Au, CJ Lane, AS Buist, and WM Vollmer. Building research capacity in middle and low-income countries through research methodology and career development education. Am J Respir Crit Care Med.. 2016;;193::A7567 .

[6] JM Hirshon, N Risko, EJ Calvello, S Stewart de Ramirez, M Narayan, and C Theodosis. Acute care research collaborative at the University of Maryland Global Health Initiative. Health systems and services: the role of acute care. Bull World Health Organ.. 2013;;91::386--8. . DOI: 10.2471/BLT.12.112664. [23678202]

[7] JA Haagsma, N Graetz, I Bolliger, M Naghavi, H Higashi, and EC Mullany. The global burden of injury: incidence, mortality, disability-adjusted life years and time trends from the Global Burden of Disease study 2013. Inj Prev.. 2016;;22::3--18. . DOI: 10.1136/injuryprev-2015-041616. [26635210]

[8] J Olivier, C Tsimpo, R Gemignani, M Shojo, H Coulombe, and F Dimmock. Understanding the roles of faith-based health-care providers in Africa: review of the evidence with a focus on magnitude, reach, cost, and satisfaction. Lancet.. 2015;;386::1765--75. . DOI: 10.1016/S0140-6736(15)60251-3. [26159398]

[9] NL Vanderford, TM Evans, LT Weiss, L Bira, and J Beltran-Gastelum. Use and effectiveness of the Individual Development Plan among postdoctoral researchers: findings from a cross-sectional study. Version 2. F1000Res.. 2018;; [revised 2018 Jan 1];7::1132 . DOI: 10.12688/f1000research.15610.1. [30498569]

[10] KL Edelblum. Young Investigator Perspectives. Networking and service through professional societies. Am J Physiol Gastrointest Liver Physiol.. 2014;;306::G359--60. . DOI: 10.1152/ajpgi.00448.2013. [24381082]



Journal of Global Health (ISSN 2047-2986), Edinburgh University Global Health Society
Designed by